about the project
Medical news
For authors
Licensed books on medicine
<< Previous Next >>

Forms of practical psychological work Comparative analysis of group and individual forms of psychological work

Sooner or later, every psychologist raises the question of how it is more productive to provide psychological assistance to a person: through individual work or by including him in a training group. Of course, professional preferences will influence the choice. However, to solve this issue, we’ll try to clarify the advantages and disadvantages that have group and individual forms of psychological assistance. In the analysis, we will rely on the advantages of psychocorrectional and psychotherapeutic work in groups that are highlighted by C. Rudestam (1993).

One of the main advantages of psychological work in a group is that group experience counteracts alienation. Such an alienation can occur during individual work with a psychologist - because the client, interacting only with a consultant, often cannot get rid of the feeling that his problem is one of a kind. There, outside the walls of the office, there are happy and carefree people who do not know how hard it is for him alone. Once in a training or psychotherapeutic group, a person avoids unproductive closure in himself with his difficulties and discovers that his problems are not unique, that others experience similar feelings. Very often in a group a person meets people who have such problems, in comparison with which their own are just flowers. And they - these other members of the group - live, act and do not lose optimism. For many people, such a discovery in itself is a powerful psychotherapeutic factor. However, if the life difficulties experienced by a person are actually much more serious than that of other participants, then work in a training group may be less useful for him than individual consultations.

Another important difference between group interaction and dyadic interaction (paired with a psychologist) is that the group is able to reflect society in miniature, making hidden factors such as partner pressure, social influence and conformism obvious. In fact, in the group, a system is modeled — brightly, convexly — of the system of relationships and interconnections that is characteristic of the real life of the participants, and this gives them the opportunity to see and analyze in psychological safety psychological patterns of communication and behavior of other people and themselves that are not obvious in everyday life situations. Indeed, in a group you can, for example, engage in role-playing games and literally recreate the specific life situations of one of the participants. Say, to put the scene of the usual school conflict, which involves several participants, and play various options for its course, to test various behavioral strategies. It is almost impossible to model the complex space of human relations in society with individual psychological work - if only because there are not enough “actors”.

In the group, the training participants have the opportunity to receive feedback and support from people with similar problems. Feedback in communication is understood as the process and result of obtaining information about the states of the communication partner and his perception of the subject's behavior. In the training group, as a rule, non-evaluative feedback is used, that is, such a message coming from the participants, which reflects, first of all, the feelings experienced by a person when perceiving the behavior of another. For example, like this: "When I see how you turn to Sergey, I feel ashamed and offended." No “labels” and any statements like “You know, Vasya, you are a brash and short-sighted person” are not allowed. In real life, not all people have the chance to receive sincere, invaluable feedback. It happens that opinions and judgments about oneself and at work and at home a person has already heard enough. But these categorical judgments, clearly evaluative, biased, biased, cannot be accepted by man - a protective psychological mechanism of denial is triggered. There are situations when in everyday life a person simply does not have the opportunity to hear at least some opinion about himself - there are no people nearby who can be completely trusted. There are no loved ones capable of complete sincerity. Yes, and it is unsafe - not always, and close ones spare us. A situation is created in the training group that allows you to see your reflection in the eyes of other people who perfectly understand the essence of your experiences, since they themselves experience almost the same thing. Each person can be a “mirror” for us, giving us our reflection. Probably there are among these "mirrors" and "curves." But the opportunity that appears in the training group to “look” at a whole gallery of “living mirrors” is, apparently, the most important advantage of group psychological work, not achievable in any other way. When a person interacts only with a psychologist in an individual consultation, he can also receive feedback. But at the same time, he has no choice - only one opinion. In the group, opinions can be expressed very different, and here a person can decide which feedback to agree with and which to reject.

When receiving psychological assistance through a group, a person can learn new skills, experiment with different styles of relationships among equal partners. If in real life such experimentation is always associated with the risk of misunderstanding, rejection and even punishment, then training groups act as a kind of “psychological training ground” where you can try to behave differently than usual, “try on” new behaviors, learn new ways treat yourself and people - and all this in an atmosphere of benevolence, acceptance and support.
The group provides an opportunity to “rehearse behavior” in certain situations in order to further transfer the best of the options found in their real life. In the case of individual work, “experimenting” with styles of relationships consists only in speaking and discussing with a psychologist the possible consequences of their transfer to reality. But preliminary testing in a circle of different types of people (which is possible in the training group) does not occur.

In the group, participants can identify themselves with others, “play” the role of another person to better understand him and themselves and to get acquainted with new effective behaviors used by someone. As a result of identification, that is, identifying oneself with another person, consciously likening oneself to him, an emotional connection, empathy, empathy arise. There is no doubt the importance of these experiences in terms of promoting personal growth and the development of self-awareness. The members of the group are not “disciples of the leader,” they learn from each other how to overcome difficulties, effective communication and interaction skills, adopt values ​​and views if they consider them acceptable for themselves. The identification mechanism, which, as is known, is one of the mechanisms of the spontaneous development of personality, becomes a reliable support in the group for changes that occur with people. Working face-to-face with a psychologist, of course, also includes identification. However, here we again find the same drawback: there is no one else to identify with the client except the psychologist, but is the personality of the psychologist always so happy with the client? In the group, however, the personalities are different, and each one can find something with which to identify.

Group interaction often creates emotional stress, which helps clarify everyone’s psychological problems. This effect does not occur with individual psychocorrectional and psychotherapeutic work - in any case, to the extent that it can be detected during the training work. Creating additional difficulties and difficulties for the facilitator, psychological stress in the group can (and should) play a constructive role, fuel the energy of fupp processes. The leader’s task is to prevent tension from getting out of control and completely destroy relations in the group. Productive conflicts help clarify the relationship between people, teach them to express genuine feelings, help to find innovative ways of interaction, set the dynamics of fuppovogo development. In individual psychological work, conflicts between the psychologist and the client are usually regarded as a destructive phenomenon or interpreted from a psychoanalytic perspective as a transfer effect.

The group, apparently, to a greater extent than individual counseling, facilitates the processes of self-disclosure, self-examination and self-knowledge. Such a statement is connected with the fact that other than through other people, these processes are fully impossible. Opening oneself to others and opening oneself to oneself allows one to understand oneself, change oneself and increase self-confidence. Work in the training opens up opportunities for the group member that are probably inaccessible to him in other conditions: interacting in specially created conditions with other people, a person freely communicates with meanings and meanings and thereby liberates his intellectual resources. He expands the field of his consciousness, strengthens faith in his own strengths, develops creative abilities, talent for communication, lays the ethical and moral foundations of practical behavior.

As with actualization in real life, a person in training follows the path of personal discoveries - he makes self-discovery. Such self-discovery generates self-discovery - for others. In order for a person to be able to reveal himself to others, he must first open himself to himself - as he is in his existential essence. Of course, such self-discovery is still superficial and unclear. Interaction with others allows him to clarify the vague image of his self. In the case of individual work with a psychologist, this process can be more extended in time.

And finally, a comparison of group and individual forms of psychological work would be incomplete without resorting to the economic aspect. If a psychologist conducts private practice, then psychological help through a group is more beneficial for him - both in time and in total payment. It is important that the group form is preferable to the clients: the participants are cheaper to work in training than individual therapy (and for many, the training work is much more effective).

Most psychotherapists and psychologists agree that practically all people who do not suffer from severe mental disorders can become participants in the training. At the same time, we note that there are people who are not at all disposed to work in fup-pe. Let us pay attention to the question of who should not be included in the training and for whom individual psychological assistance is more preferable. According to a number of experts, people with very high anxiety, overly emotional, capable of strong manifestations of affectiveness, people with low self-esteem (with the exception of special self-confidence training), and conflicting personalities are not suitable for participating in fupp work. Most likely, pronounced introverts will feel uncomfortable in the fupp.

With all people with these characteristics, it is likely that individual psychological work will be more effective.
<< Previous Next >>
= Skip to textbook content =

Forms of practical psychological work Comparative analysis of group and individual forms of psychological work

  1. forms of individual and group work of a psychotherapist
    A psychotherapist can use various methods of individual and group work to provide psychological assistance. At the same time, the corresponding goals and objectives are solved: • study of the patient’s personality, its emotional response, motivation, relationship system, identification of the reasons contributing to both the emergence and preservation of personality problems; • achieving patient awareness and
  2. Forms of individual and group work of a psychologist
    A military psychologist can use various methods of individual and group work * to provide psychological assistance. At the same time, the corresponding goals and objectives are solved: studying the client’s personality, his emotional response, motivation, relationship system, identifying the reasons that contribute to both the emergence and preservation of personality problems; achieving customer awareness
  3. Practical psychological work as a type of activity of psychologists
    The main goal of practical psychological work is direct psychological assistance to people who need it. Practical psychologists help in solving problems arising in the fields of education, medicine, industrial activity, social and personal life of people. The key figures in practical psychological work are the customer, client and psychologist. Customer,
    (based on the materials of the Guidelines for psychological work in the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation. Appendix 12) Social and psychological training (SPT). Individual and group communication training allows you to increase the socio-psychological competence of a person: his psychological sensitivity, contact, ability to orientate in complex interpersonal situations, etc. Organization of the training.
  5. Recommendations to officials on the organization of educational work, taking into account the individual psychological characteristics of the military
    The need to develop recommendations for officials arises, as a rule, regarding military personnel with unsatisfactory psychological stability (1, 2 points on the “Forecast-2-02” questionnaire; according to the NPU scale of the personality questionnaire “NPN-A-02”; according to the NPU methodology scale “Adaptability-02 (MLO)”). Neuropsychic resistance with such indicators limits adaptive capabilities
  6. The work of the unit commander for the study of individual psychological characteristics of personnel and the preservation of the mental health of military personnel
    Students of a higher military educational institution, like members of any other collective, differ from each other in a variety of individual traits: level of consciousness, general development, culture, education, interests, abilities, character, physical development, etc. Along with this, cadets of various courses of study also differ from one another in a number of features,
  7. Forms of group work of a psychologist
    Teamwork Forms
  8. Option of recommendations and suggestions to the officers of the regiment (ship of the 1st rank) on the organization of educational work, taking into account the individual psychological characteristics of the military.
    The need to develop recommendations for officials arises, as a rule, regarding military personnel with moderate signs of neuropsychic instability, (4, 5, 6 sten on the “Forecast-2” questionnaire; 5, 6, 7 sten on the NPN scale of the personal questionnaire “NPN- A "; 4, 3 sten according to the NPU scale of the Adaptability method). Neuropsychic instability at such rates
  9. Appendix No. 3 Option of recommendations and proposals to officials of the regiment (ship of the 1st rank) on the organization of educational work, taking into account the individual psychological characteristics of the military
    to Art. 20 of the Manual, approved by order of the Minister of Defense of the Russian Federation in 1997 N___ Option of recommendations and proposals to officials of the regiment (ship of the 1st rank) on the organization of educational work, taking into account the individual psychological characteristics of the military. The need to develop recommendations for officials arises, as a rule, regarding
  11. The system of work of the organizers of the psychological work of the branches of the Armed Forces, branches of the armed forces, main and central departments of the Ministry of Defense of the Russian Federation, psychologists of the troops (forces) to prevent suicides of military personnel
    The Main Directorate of Educational Work of the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation Conducts Daily: Analysis of information on the moral and psychological state of troops (forces), military units, reasons for committing suicides, development of measures to prevent them: interaction with the operational information center of the Main Directorate of Educational Work of the Armed Forces
  12. Analysis of the results of psychological analysis of the 1st and 2nd periods of activity led to the following understanding of the generalized structure of the state of psychological readiness
    It consists, as it were, of two motivated-volitional components: k-1 and k-2 k-1: motives of responsibility and duty, a state of confidence; K-2: motives of hostilities, a state of decisiveness. Moreover, the structure of the “state of confidence” is the motive for success; self-confidence, calculation; self-control; experiencing the state significance of the success of their activities. The structure of the “state
  13. Основные формы и методы изучения индивидуально-психологических особенностей военнослужащих
    Основные формы и методы изучения индивидуально-психологических особенностей
  14. Основы психологической работы
    Психологическая работа – это система согласованных, целенаправленных мероприятий, осуществляемых с использованием достижений психологической науки в интересах жизнедеятельности войск (сил), по поддержанию психологической устойчивости личного состава и сохранению психического здоровья военнослужащих. Основные задачи психологической работы: ? изучение индивидуально-психологических
  15. Оценка эффективности психологической работы
    Эффективность психологической работы оценивается в соответствии с требованиями приказа Министра обороны Российской Федерации 2004 года № 70. Оценивая психологическую работу необходимо проанализировать и установить: влияние психологической работы на формирование морально-психологической устойчивости и готовности военнослужащих к выполнению задач в любых условиях обстановки, высокой
    Курирование больных. Применение практических навыков. Участие (ассистирование) в проведении неотложных лечебных мероприятий (внутрисосудистое введение лекарственных средств, спинномозговая пункция и др.). Участие в клинических обходах и разборах начальника кафедры, заместителя начальника кафедры, профессоров кафедры. Прием больных в приемном отделении клиники
  17. Направления психологической работы
    Как и любой обслуживающий вид деятельности, психологическая работа связана с необходимостью решения конкретных проблем, оказывающих негативное влияние на уровень боевой готовности. Психологическая работа направлена на решение личностных, коллективно-групповых и деятельных проблем. Личностные проблемы – это проблемы, ухудшающие личностное развитие военнослужащих, их нравственное и
  18. Роль командира в укреплении воинской дисциплины в подразделении: методика анализа, содержание и основные формы воспитательной работы
    В современных условиях с особой силой звучат слова о том, что высокая организованность и крепкая дисциплина необходимы везде, они обеспечивают успех в любой области человеческой деятельности. Повышение ответственности, развитие инициативы, деловитости, предприимчивости, воспитание сознательной дисциплины и нетерпимости к недостаткам приобретают решающее значение. Сознательная дисциплина,
  19. Принципы организации психологической работы
    Основополагающим условием эффективности психологической работы являются исходные базовые установки – принципы, система которых включает довольно широкий набор требований к ее организации и проведению. Принцип профессиональной компетенции, правовой и этической правомочности. Требования данного принципа ориентируют всех должностных лиц психологической работы на четкое представление и учет
    11. Общее организационно-методическое руководство психологической работой в Вооруженных Силах осуществляет Главное управление воспитательной работы Вооруженных Сил Российской Федерации (далее Главное управление воспитательной работы). Главное управление воспитательной работы осуществляет взаимодействие по вопросам психологической работы с военными и гражданскими учебными и
Medical portal "MedguideBook" © 2014-2019