home
about the project
Medical news
For authors
Licensed books on medicine
<< Previous Next >>

WHY PSYCHOLOGY CAN BE CALLED AS SCIENCE

Serious scientists (for example, studying the physics or biochemistry of roundworms) often question the status of psychology as a science. The most sensible people, who have resisted the temptation to professionally engage in science, consider psychology as an applied discipline with vague terminology ("muttering psychos").

Be that as it may, if you want to impress the psychologist, you must firmly defend the view that psychology is truly a science. To evaluate this statement, a little history should be learned. Of course, this is human nature, but let it not bother you, you do not need to know more about the history of psychology than a psychologist, and this is quite a bit.

Origins: does philosophy have evidence?

The history of psychology is quite short. For more than 2500 years, no one has been indignant that philosophers have been engaged in psychology (Aristotle, Socrates, a little later Descartes, who can be scolded for separating the soul from the body as a “ghost in a car” became a good example). These wise loafers reflected on the human mind, and not a single scientist bothered them with a small request for evidence. At sunset of the 19th century, a coup finally took place. Scientists wanted to make sure on the basis of facts, whether there is a grain of truth in the absurd statements of philosophers. Thus began the period of empirical psychology.

From that moment, important ideas concerning the mind began to be verified by the method of experiments - that is, the theory was followed by experiments in which the hypothesis was tested. Failure meant a nail in the coffin for the whole theory. It happens!

Unfortunately, psychologists are just people and can be equally shy and persistent, so many theories were undeservedly forgotten, while others were stubbornly insisted on, without having the slightest evidence of their truth.

You might want to know that the first psychological laboratory was founded by Wilhelm Wundt (1832–1920) in 1879 at the University of Leipzig, but this is only useful if you plan to communicate with a German. Wundt was the founder of German gestalt psychologists - early experts in the field of visual perception. Representatives of this direction study how people perceive and classify what is in front of their eyes (ears, nose, etc.). The most famous principle is: “The whole is always greater than the sum of its constituent parts” and is applied not only to optical illusion, but also to churches from matches, magic pies and the ABBA group.

William James (1842–1910), brother of novelist Henry James, was Wundt’s distinguished American rival. He helpfully defined psychology as the “science of spiritual life” and worked as a slave for 12 years to write his famous book, Principles of Psychology (you should make it a rule to call it “James”). In 1884, James excellently formulated James-Lange's theory of feelings, which Karl Lange (1834–1900) had worked on the year before.

According to the James-Lange theory, the emergence of emotions is caused by changes caused by external influences in the voluntary motor sphere, as well as in the field of involuntary acts of cardiac, vascular, secretory activity. The set of sensations associated with these changes is an emotional experience. James illustrates this with the example that psychologists have repeatedly quoted: a person realizes his fear of a bear only after he reacted to his attack (for example, he ran away or noted in his mind that next year it is not worth spending a vacation in Yosemite National Park) .

It should be noted that psychologists are still arguing about the dubious places of the James-Lange theory. This serves as convincing evidence that psychology is indeed a “difficult” science or that many psychologists are incorrigible in their desire to engage in advanced science.

Transition: Psychology Neglects Scientific Precision

While empirical psychologists puzzled over the question of how to make psychology a true science, the psychiatrist Sigmund Freud (1856-1939) unexpectedly came up with a new direction - psychoanalysis. And that ruined everything. Freud was not going to test his ideas by the method of scientific experiments, so in academic textbooks on psychology they do not pay enough attention. And psychology textbooks, if you've ever read them, are a great way to promote ideas.

Despite this, Freud was the first to explain the serious role of parent-child relationships and their impact on internal conflicts in the unconscious during puberty.
Freud is largely considered the "father" of psychology, and so far his work gives rise to a deep unconscious (and conscious) struggle between psychologists. We recommend that you get acquainted with Freud's inspirational ideas in your home environment, but in public do not forget to scold him for the lack of scientific accuracy. This will convince others in the depths of your knowledge. They don’t speak badly about the dead, but Freud is an exception.



The era of behaviorism: psychology again requires evidence (this time very serious)

Against psychoanalysis, sparing no effort, a movement was struggling that required the restoration of scientific morality. It was behaviorism founded by John Watson (1878–1958), Ivan Pavlov (1849–1936) and B. F. Skinner (1904–1990). Watson did not value reflection and empathy (the ability to empathize) as highly as his contemporaries, psychoanalysts. He argued: “The goal of psychology is not in understanding experience, but in predicting and controlling behavior!” To achieve this, behaviorists built unnatural devices, such as the Skinner’s box, designed to monitor and control the reactions of rats, dogs, and pigeons. It was assumed that these experiments will reveal the laws of natural behavior of people.

Behavioralists avoided studying human experiences as if it were a dubious area, and allotted it a place somewhere between mysticism and fiction. Mental experiences were described as a “concomitant phenomenon,” that is, something happening on the surface is a consequence of what is happening in reality, but does not affect anyone or anything. About the same as the political manifesto.

Cognitive revolution: psychology is obsessed with computers (like everyone else)

In the 1940-1950s, under the leadership of the American mathematician Norbert Wiener (1894-1964), a new movement arose, called cybernetics, and the mind again entered the stage. In cybernetics, the human mind is regarded as a complex type of thermostat that regulates all processes to maintain a satisfactory state of the system. If you claim that you are familiar with this discipline, then no one will doubt that you are a graduate. This trend did not last long and turned into a broad movement, now known as cognitive psychology.

Cognitive psychologists have put forward the important idea that the study of the human mind is possible based on the study of computer operation. It can be assumed that the main obstacle to its development was that psychologists know very little about computer operation. Only they drew an analogy between the mind existing in the brain and the "software" operating in the hardware of the computer, as true researchers of the brain reminded them that such an analogy is also meaningless. Computers must be identical, while two identical brains cannot be found, with the possible exception of the brains of Tony Blair and George W. Bush.

End result: mess

As you can see, the development of psychology can be traced on the example of vivid analogies that psychologists themselves use. Over the past century, the science of human behavior has been based on the behavior of a dog, rat, pigeon, thermostat, computer, and will soon get to the behavior of a gaming machine. And only philosophers need to pay tribute to the original (and most robust) idea to study the human mind on the basis of the human mind.

The cumulative effect of the development of various areas in psychology is that there is no time to study all of this, as a result, each individual psychologist remains adherent only of his own precious discipline, while at the same time affirming that all the others are as essential as a certain arrangement of people in a round dance .

Therefore, although psychologists declare their ability to understand other people, one psychologist is unlikely to understand what the other is talking about. Fortunately, you are free to choose what you like best and to rant with others. For example, you can say ...

• behaviorist: “If my thoughts are a related phenomenon, I think you are not very upset about what I think about your inexcusably screaming tie.”

• to a cognitive psychologist: “If a computer is like a human brain, tell me what my laptop really wants from life.”

• psychoanalyst (after he, based on your way of holding a cup, made a conclusion about your subconscious motives moving you): “Terrific! How do you think my cup feels? ”
<< Previous Next >>
= Skip to textbook content =

WHY PSYCHOLOGY CAN BE CALLED AS SCIENCE

  1. Psychology is becoming an independent science
    The development of psychology as an independent science dates back to the second half of the 19th century. Objective research methods are becoming increasingly important. Many psychologists consider them more scientifically sound than the introspective method that has been used for a long time to study human consciousness. Psychological research increasingly uses measurements, which is becoming important
  2. I believe that giving birth to children is a big responsibility. It can even be called a lifetime contract. When I think I can hurt them, I feel bad. What do I need to do to think differently?
    Change your beliefs. Firstly, when you decide to have a baby, you should not think that you are responsible for his happiness. Your first motivation should be the desire to enable the soul to return in order to be embodied. It is a gift of self. Then, to continue your growth, you must learn to love this soul that has chosen you. Having a baby is
  3. Where can I become a psychologist right after school?
    Here I will provide some information about state higher education institutions that train psychologists. Like it or not, the prestige of state universities is still higher than private ones. Someday this will change. Where they could, they indicated the conditions of admission, telephones, the competition that was in previous years, and other information that may be of interest to the applicant. UNIVERSITIES OF MOSCOW Moscow State
  4. What can be said about special creams for inflammation of the nipples? How can I get them during an emergency?
    Unfortunately, sometimes creams and aerosols for nipples are sent along with humanitarian aid. Do not use them. Most of these products exacerbate nipple inflammation, destroying the natural protective fats in the areola. Breast sucking cannot aggravate nipple inflammation if the baby is properly seized in the mouth. Inflammation and cracked nipples begin to heal within 24 hours after
  5. Is it possible to LOSE QUICKLY, and HOW QUICKLY can LOSE?
    I know from experience that this question is asked one of the first in each lecture. We are always in a hurry somewhere. The "speed" of losing weight always depends on several factors. From age, general hormonal background, type of obesity and associated pathology, etc. The complex technique developed by me is based on personal experience, as well as on the use of the latest achievements and discoveries in the field of biochemistry
  6. Can I learn to write fast?
    You were not mistaken by reading the title of this section. You can write quickly, or rather, take notes. Scientists have developed a special system called speed notes. The author of the technique, L. F. Sternberg, argues that it is relatively easy to learn to take notes two to three times faster, and this system is much simpler than shorthand. Let's look at the elements
  7. AFTERWORD YOU CAN MISS
    Where does this yellow brick road lead me to? At a seminar for active work they asked me: “What is your most important intention? Now we will promote it to you! ” From surprise, I joked: “I wish you world fame!” Apparently, my desire was non-trivial, because the leading one was a little skewed from surprise. He whistled, but did not hesitate: “World fame is easy!” Renamed
  8. Is it possible to do without porridge?
    Can! But you still have to reconsider your attitude to skin and food. And review thoroughly. Here's how it turned out with the Flying Cat - here is her diary (Flying is for real: The cat flies on all sorts of paragliders and parachutes). Koshkina figurine - silk skin June 23: Today, an organism exhausted by a martini with beer, work and a spring allergy finally rebelled and accepted a strong-willed
  9. Can people be judged by their appearance?
    It is well known that a person, like a chicken, comes from an egg. At a very early stage, the human embryo is a three-layer tube, the inner layer of which turns into the stomach and lungs, the middle layer into bones, muscles, connective tissue and blood vessels, and the outer layer into the skin and nervous system. Usually these three layers grow at approximately the same pace, so the average
  10. Can cerebral palsy be cured?
    The question of the “treatment” of cerebral palsy, the miraculous drugs, the clinics where the “100% cure” is guaranteed, constantly worries parents. Even having learned over time not to believe frankly advertising articles and promises, parents continue to doubt: “Or maybe it will be here that they will help and cure?” Nowhere in the world is there a method of therapy, medication or other
  11. Can mental illness be cured?
    As new treatments are introduced, more psychoses and neuroses can be cured. Thousands of psychiatrists and chemists around the world are working on this problem. Every year there is some progress in a particular area, and there are years when an important discovery is made. A person with psychiatric symptoms can improve in two ways. He either "does
  12. To summarize: is it possible to get rid of vitiligo?
    Yes you can. In order to prevent the further progression of the process, it is necessary, if possible, to establish the cause and eliminate it. Further, it is necessary to act directly on the foci of vitiligo. It has been proven that there is a reserve of melanocytes in skin lacking pigment. These melanocytes are located in the mouths of the hair follicles. In order to make them work and they started their
  13. Why can I use the method
    An example showed that with the help of intelligence cards it is possible to display and organize a variety of information. They can be used in a variety of situations and for different purposes. • Creative thinking and brainstorming: collecting and structuring your ideas, as a team or individually. Develop professional and personal perspectives and goals. • Information management: management,
  14. But still, is it possible to read textbooks quickly?
    Yes you can. But, of course, this method can be used not as a reading method for in-depth study of the subject, but as an additional, very effective tool. We strongly recommend that you use the super-fast reading method - the “assault method” at all stages of the learning process: for the initial study of a new subject, during the school year, as well as during the preparation for exams.
  15. Is it possible to feed a baby artificially without a bottle?
    Yes. Cups are safer than bottles because nipples and screw caps on bottles collect pathogens on their surface that enter the milk and cause the baby’s illness. Children from birth can drink from a cup. Some people worry that the baby needs to suck a pacifier. But it’s safer for children to suck their own fingers. In addition, children fed from
  16. What can be said about premature or small babies?
    As we said earlier, the more vulnerable the baby is, the more important it is for him to get breast milk. Breastfeeding creates less stress for a premature or small baby who can breastfeed than bottle feeding.If the baby is deeply premature or too weak to breastfeed, it can be fed through a tube (food probe) with your expressed milk. You can quite
  17. Part 6: Why
    Our brain is not satisfied with the knowledge of what exactly is in front of us, in what quantity, where exactly, when this or that event occurs and how the objects interact with each other. Cause and effect - things are certainly important, but in fact our brain wants to know the answer to the question "why." Why is one thing happening and not the other? Why does something happen time after time and something happens
  18. Signs by which you can determine the disease in the child
    Anamnestic information In connection with the increase in the number of children with developmental disabilities, it became necessary to establish special counseling centers that examine such children, as well as preschool institutions in which children can receive qualified medical, defectological and psychological assistance. Currently, the number of children with
Medical portal "MedguideBook" © 2014-2019
info@medicine-guidebook.com