home
about the project
Medical news
For authors
Licensed books on medicine
<< Previous Next >>

Obligations of patients as subjects of medical legal relations

It should be noted that the study of the responsibilities of persons receiving medical care as an integral part of the legal status of patients is a poorly studied area of ​​modern legal support for the field of medical activity. The reasons for this legal situation are a number of factors, which may include the following.

1. Perception of patients as a more vulnerable category of subjects of medical legal relations in the system of "medical worker-patient"

2. The essence of the provision of medical care implies that some individuals (entities receiving medical care), due to a deterioration in their health status, acquire the right (but not obligation) to receive medical care, while others (entities providing medical assistance) , by virtue of their professional affiliation, are given the duty (but do not have the right at will) to alleviate the suffering of the patient.

3. The constitutional norm, testifying to the fact that every citizen has the right to protection of health and medical care. It is, first of all, about citizens who seek medical help and are endowed, in this regard, with the rights of the patient. The norms that give the patient any obligations in the field of medical activity, the basic law of the country does not contain. In particular, article 41 of the Constitution of the Russian Federation states that "in the Russian Federation, federal programs for the protection and promotion of public health are financed, activities (italics A.P.) that promote human health are encouraged ..." * (128). That is, the activity of citizens aimed at improving health by the state is encouraged, but citizens are not burdened with the performance of duties related to maintaining or improving their health.

Do the facts cited indicate the absence of obligations on patients and, in this regard, on the unnecessary inclusion of a sign called "duties" in the legal status of patients? According to the author, the answer is no. In previous studies on the legal relationship between medical workers and patients, the author has already dwelled on this problem. In particular, when receiving medical care, the patient has the right to receive information and manage the process of correcting his painful condition, without possessing, at the same time, the necessary knowledge. At the same time, a medical professional who has professional training, and, at times, considerable experience, is obliged to obey the desires and whims of the patient. In this situation, the medical worker is responsible for the course and result of the treatment process, which he is not able to fully control. In other words, we are moving from medical authoritarianism to the exact opposite - consumer extremism * (129).

So what are the patient’s responsibilities? It seems that the current state of the regulatory framework, the rich history of the legal regulation of medical activity in Russia, the influence of the moral, ethical and biomedical principles and provisions mentioned above indicate the possibility and necessity of highlighting the following patient responsibilities:

- compliance with the instructions of the attending physician regarding the administration of medicines and the implementation of prescribed medical diagnostic procedures,

- compliance with the regime of work and rest, physical activity, diet, associated with the correction of the patient's painful condition;

- compliance with the internal rules of the medical institution and the implementation of the recommendations of medical personnel in the case of medical care in a hospital;

- the implementation of periodic preventive medical measures at the time recommended by medical personnel;

- compliance with sanitary and hygienic requirements and rules of behavior that prevent the spread of dangerous infectious diseases (tuberculosis, hepatitis, HIV infection, sexually transmitted diseases, etc.).

If the legal consolidation of the listed obligations of patients at the level of legislative acts can still be considered only in the future, then, within the framework of bilateral contracts for the provision of medical care, at the level of by-laws (departmental) regulatory legal acts, it is perfectly acceptable to assign to patients the fulfillment of these and other duties.
It is advisable, in particular, to fix in the protocols for the treatment of certain diseases (approved by orders of the Ministry of Health and Social Development of the Russian Federation) the fulfillment by patients of certain duties aimed at improving the state of health and increasing the effectiveness of the performed medical intervention.

For example, Order of the Ministry of Health and Social Development of the Russian Federation of November 22, 2004 N 239 "On approval of the standard of care for patients with atherosclerosis" contains three sections: patient model, diagnosis and treatment without exacerbation at the rate of 6 months * (130). In particular, recommendations on adhering to the work and rest regimen, diet, medical appointments, albeit in a mild form, but nevertheless, could be expressed in the form of the patient’s responsibilities aimed at achieving a positive result of the treatment, which would certainly be very helpful. This approach to the legal relationship of medical workers and patients can be very effective, since both subjects of medical-legal relations will be interested in improving the patient’s health and in minimizing the negative consequences, complications, the development of which is possible in the process of providing medical care.
<< Previous Next >>
= Skip to textbook content =

Obligations of patients as subjects of medical legal relations

  1. The patient - as a subject of medical-legal relations
    The study of the issues of legal support of medical activity cannot be complete without an analysis of the legal status of such an important subject of medical and legal relations as a patient. The patient, as a subject of medico-legal relations in the field of medical activity, is a key figure with whom all other subjects are connected in one way or another, who, to one degree or another, accept
  2. Legal guarantees for the implementation of the rights and freedoms of patients as subjects of medical and legal relations
    Theoretical aspects of the formation of the legal status of a patient in modern Russia justifiably include issues of guaranteeing the realization of the rights of patients. What are safeguards mechanisms, which public or private organizations are responsible for creating the conditions and safeguards that facilitate the practical realization of patients' rights? Answers to these and other questions
  3. Rights and freedoms of patients - subjects of medical legal relations
    The rights and freedoms of citizens receiving medical care began to be actualized in the Russian Federation in the 90s of the last century. Over the past 15 years, the rights of patients, as subjects of medical-legal relations, have been legislatively enshrined in the modern Constitution of the Russian Federation (adopted by popular vote on December 12, 1993), in a number of Federal laws: "On medical
  4. Medical and legal ethics. Theoretical and legal substantiation of the principles and its place in the system of social regulation of the sphere of medical activity
    Revealing the peculiarities of the correlation of ethical principles and rules with the rule of law, a combination of legal and ethical levels of regulation of the sphere of medical activity, it is advisable to dwell on highlighting the development prospects of medical and legal ethics - a new complex interdisciplinary branch of knowledge. Domestic legal and medical scientific literature contains conflicting
  5. Improving medical and legal educational programs in the context of improving the effectiveness of legal regulation of domestic health care
    Conducting research in the field of training medical and legal personnel in the context of studying issues related to the legal provision of health care seems to be sufficiently substantiated. This is due, first of all, to the fact that: - the teaching of legal regulation of healthcare in the organizational and legal aspect is directly related to the system, as
  6. The concept and types of legal status of the patient
    A clear definition of the "legal status of the patient" is justified by the need for further research on this medical and legal phenomenon. In this regard, the author offers the following definition of the legal status of the patient. The legal status of the patient is a system of rights, freedoms, legal guarantees of their realization and protection of legal
  7. The mechanism of legal regulation of public relations in the field of medical activity
    Research in the field of legal regulation in the field of medical activity seems relevant in the context of the need to constantly improve the legal regulation of public relations arising in the process of providing medical care. In terms of understanding the mechanism of legal regulation, as a set of legal means by which the impact
  8. The legal status of a patient in modern Russia
    The legal status of the patient in modern
  9. Patient Partnerships
    An integral part of measures for the long-term prevention of MTR in patients with hypertension should be an increase in the educational level of patients. Even if we assume that for each particular patient with hypertension, the doctor will develop an optimal program of drug and non-drug treatment, then it will be very difficult to implement it if there is a low motivation for treatment. To the doctor
  10. Correlation of moral, ethical and legal categories in the regulation of public relations in the field of medical activity
    Correlation of moral, ethical and legal categories in the regulation of public relations in the field of medical
  11. Personality as a subject of life's journey
    As noted, the special quality of a personality that arises in interaction with circumstances and in resolving life contradictions is its quality as a subject. The category of personality as a subject of life means not only what the person realizes, creates, directs his life, but also how, at what level, with what degree of completeness and depth, he lives his life. S.L. Rubinshtein
  12. Personality as a subject of life's journey
    As noted, the special quality of a personality that arises in interaction with circumstances and in resolving life contradictions is its quality as a subject. The category of personality as a subject of life means not only what the person realizes, creates, directs his life, but also how, at what level, with what degree of completeness and depth, he lives his life. S.L.
  13. REorganization of an Organism as a Subject of Targeted Actions
    All the previous exposition serves as a proof that the concept of the subject is of fundamental importance for psychology. Its recognition or denial decisively affects the construction of a picture of mental activity and the nature of psychological views. If we exclude from psychology the concept of a subject of purposeful objective activity, as all the “scientific” bourgeois did
  14. Self-understanding of the subject as a problem of the psychology of human being
    Modern psychology is characterized by many not only areas and directions of research, but also various methods of methodological reflection of the content and structure of psychological knowledge. One of the options for a new methodology for understanding human life is the psychology of the subject. Today, in Russian psychological science, the category of the subject plays a system-forming role, and this is not
  15. Acmeologist as a subject of activity in the acmeological service
    Consideration of an acmeologist as a subject of activity within the framework of an acmeological service involves an appeal to his duties, responsibilities, rights, as well as personal and professional characteristics. In his professional activity, an acmeologist is obliged: - to be guided by the Constitution of the Russian Federation, government and regulatory documents regulating the activities of relevant structures,
  16. Student psychologist as a subject of educational and professional activity
    In modern pedagogy and pedagogical psychology, the traditional scheme of relations between teachers and students has long been abandoned, when the teacher acts as the "bearer" of knowledge and its active "guide" to the consciousness of students, i.e. acts as a "subject of the educational process", and students only "perceive" the proposed knowledge, while actually remaining passive
Medical portal "MedguideBook" © 2014-2019
info@medicine-guidebook.com