home
about the project
Medical news
For authors
Licensed books on medicine
<< Previous Next >>

The patient - as a subject of medical-legal relations

The study of the issues of legal support of medical activity cannot be complete without an analysis of the legal status of such an important subject of medical and legal relations as a patient. The patient, as the subject of medical and legal relations in the field of medical activity, is a key figure with whom all other subjects are connected in one way or another, who, to one degree or another, take part in organizing, providing or directly providing medical care. It would not be an exaggeration to note that without patients, the functioning of the entire healthcare sector loses much of its meaning.

It should be noted that just like crime, a social phenomenon that always accompanies society, even in the most civilized and highly developed democracies, illness is a social phenomenon, from which even with the highest level of development of medicine and the most careful attitude of citizens to their own health, it is not possible to get rid completely. In this regard, it is no coincidence that one of the priority principles of the health care system is prevention, since the effectiveness of preventive measures is not equal in comparison with other methods aimed at solving the main social tasks of the state in preserving and enhancing the health of the population.

Given the central place of the patient in the field of health care, it seems appropriate to dwell on the study of problems associated with the legal status of the patient in modern Russia. The range of opinions on this issue is very wide. Starting from the fact that patients in our country are practically disenfranchised, and ending with the fact that Russia is in the leading position in the world in terms of legislative support for the rights of patients. Consider this problem in more detail.

Initially, it becomes necessary to determine the patient’s place in the system of medical and legal relations from the point of view of legal theory. The importance of this issue is dictated by the advisability of studying the rights, freedoms, duties and other components of the patient’s legal status, since it is a detailed study that will provide comprehensive coverage of this phenomenon and, importantly, will facilitate the integration of medical and legal phenomena into the system of the theory of legal science. It is the theory of law, based on its fundamental nature and purpose, on the theoretical study of sectoral legal phenomena, that can contribute to the development of medical law as an independent branch of law. In addition, it is the use of general provisions and principles of the theory of law that allows you to analyze in detail such a complex legal phenomenon as the legal status of the patient.

Considering through the prism of the theoretical and legal constructions of the patient as a subject of medical and legal relations, it is necessary, first of all, to give a clear definition of this concept. S.G. Stetsenko believes that “a patient is a person who has applied to a medical institution for diagnostic, medical or preventive medical care or who is involved as a test subject in clinical trials of drugs. In other words, a person must have a real relationship (legal relationship) ) with a medical institution, regardless of its legal form (state, municipal, private), based on the person’s appeal to this institution ezhdenie medical care or his participation in clinical trials, "* (111).

The Patient Rights Bill in the United States contains a definition according to which “a patient is any individual who receives long- or short-term inpatient or outpatient care, emergency or emergency care, and also a client of facilities for long-term care or care" * (112 ) That is, in accordance with this definition, a citizen who applied to a medical institution for a certificate of his state of health cannot be considered a patient.

Even when applying to a medical institution for an extract from a medical record, a certificate of health status, the results of preventive or dispensary examinations conducted earlier or over the course of a number of years, a citizen acquires a special status as a person who has entered into a relationship with a medical institution.
Even if this appeal does not involve any medical interventions, a citizen is vested with certain rights and obligations, and, therefore, gets the right to get acquainted with medical documents and dispose of confidential information regarding his state of health.

In turn, V.I. Akopov and E.N. Maslov noted that “any person who seeks medical care is considered to be a patient, regardless of their state of health or the presence of any disease, that is, it is a broader concept than a patient” * (113).

One should agree with the latter definition, since the term “patient” is indeed a broader concept than the term “patient” and is not related to the presence or absence of a disease. In real life, not all sick people, i.e. those who have deviations in their health state turn to medical institutions for medical help. We are talking about cases of self-medication at home or a citizen's refusal from the proposed medical intervention. In these cases, citizens who do not seek medical help, even if they suffer from diseases, cannot be considered patients, since they have not entered into legal relations with medical workers, that is, they have not accepted the rights and obligations inherent in the subject of medical law relationship.

Considering the above facts, the author believes that the patient is a person who has entered into legal relations with a medical worker (medical institution), and is endowed, in this regard, with specific laws, freedoms and obligations of the subject of medical and legal relations fixed by the state in law.

It should be noted that neither the place of medical care, nor the state of health of a person in need of medical care, are of great importance for determining the legal status of the patient. In particular, medical personnel of the ambulance team provide emergency medical care exclusively outside medical facilities. Moreover, in accordance with the requirements of the current legislation of the Russian Federation, medical workers of any specialty are required to provide first aid to citizens, regardless of location, time of day, the availability of necessary tools and medicines.

At the same time, it is not uncommon for citizens to go to a medical institution, in the absence of signs of illness, in order to conduct a dispensary, preventive or other examination necessary to obtain a certificate of health status, vaccination, employment, etc. In all of these In cases, a citizen, without suffering any disease, enters into legal relations with medical workers or medical institutions. As a result, he is endowed with certain rights, obligations, and, therefore, acquires the specific legal status of the patient as a subject of medical-legal relations.

In this regard, it seems necessary to consider the legal status of the patient as a complex theoretical and legal phenomenon that includes such characteristics as legal personality, fundamental rights, duties, responsibilities, guarantees for the realization of his rights and freedoms.
<< Previous Next >>
= Skip to textbook content =

The patient - as a subject of medical-legal relations

  1. Obligations of patients as subjects of medical legal relations
    It should be noted that the study of the duties of persons receiving medical care as an integral part of the legal status of patients is a poorly studied area of ​​modern legal support for the field of medical activity. The reasons for this legal situation are a number of factors, which may include the following. 1. Perception of patients as a more vulnerable category
  2. Legal guarantees for the implementation of the rights and freedoms of patients as subjects of medical and legal relations
    Theoretical aspects of the formation of the legal status of a patient in modern Russia justifiably include issues of guaranteeing the realization of the rights of patients. What are safeguards mechanisms, which public or private organizations are responsible for creating the conditions and safeguards that facilitate the practical realization of patients' rights? Answers to these and other questions
  3. Rights and freedoms of patients - subjects of medical legal relations
    The rights and freedoms of citizens receiving medical care began to be actualized in the Russian Federation in the 90s of the last century. Over the past 15 years, the rights of patients, as subjects of medical-legal relations, have been legislatively enshrined in the modern Constitution of the Russian Federation (adopted by popular vote on December 12, 1993), in a number of Federal laws: "On medical
  4. Medical and legal ethics. Theoretical and legal substantiation of the principles and its place in the system of social regulation of the sphere of medical activity
    Revealing the peculiarities of the correlation of ethical principles and rules with the rule of law, a combination of legal and ethical levels of regulation of the sphere of medical activity, it is advisable to dwell on highlighting the development prospects of medical and legal ethics - a new complex interdisciplinary branch of knowledge. Domestic legal and medical scientific literature contains conflicting
  5. Improving medical and legal educational programs in the context of improving the effectiveness of legal regulation of domestic health care
    Conducting research in the field of training medical and legal personnel in the context of studying issues related to the legal provision of health care seems to be sufficiently substantiated. This is due, first of all, to the fact that: - teaching the issues of legal regulation of healthcare in the organizational and legal aspect is directly related to the system, as
  6. The concept and types of legal status of the patient
    A clear definition of the "legal status of the patient" is justified by the need for further research on this medical and legal phenomenon. In this regard, the author offers the following definition of the legal status of the patient. The legal status of the patient is a system of rights, freedoms, legal guarantees of their realization and protection of legal
  7. The mechanism of legal regulation of public relations in the field of medical activity
    Research in the field of legal regulation in the field of medical activity seems relevant in the context of the need to constantly improve the legal regulation of social relations arising in the process of providing medical care. In terms of understanding the mechanism of legal regulation, as a set of legal means by which the impact
  8. The legal status of a patient in modern Russia
    The legal status of the patient in modern
  9. Patient Partnerships
    An integral part of measures for the long-term prevention of MTR in patients with hypertension should be an increase in the educational level of patients. Even if we assume that for each particular patient with hypertension, the doctor will develop an optimal program of drug and non-drug treatment, then it will be very difficult to implement it if there is a low motivation for treatment. To the doctor
  10. Correlation of moral, ethical and legal categories in the regulation of public relations in the field of medical activity
    Correlation of moral, ethical and legal categories in the regulation of public relations in the field of medical
  11. Personality as a subject of life's journey
    As noted, the special quality of a personality that arises in interaction with circumstances and in resolving life contradictions is its quality as a subject. The category of personality as a subject of life means not only what the person realizes, creates, directs his life, but also how, at what level, with what degree of completeness and depth, he lives his life. S.L. Rubinshtein
  12. Personality as a subject of life's journey
    As noted, the special quality of a personality that arises in interaction with circumstances and in resolving life contradictions is its quality as a subject. The category of personality as a subject of life means not only what the person realizes, creates, directs his life, but also how, at what level, with what degree of completeness and depth, he lives his life. S.L.
  13. REorganization of an Organism as a Subject of Targeted Actions
    All the previous exposition serves as a proof that the concept of the subject is of fundamental importance for psychology. Its recognition or denial decisively affects the construction of a picture of mental activity and the nature of psychological views. If we exclude from psychology the concept of a subject of purposeful objective activity, as all the “scientific” bourgeois did
  14. Self-understanding of the subject as a problem of the psychology of human being
    Modern psychology is characterized by many not only areas and directions of research, but also various methods of methodological reflection of the content and structure of psychological knowledge. One of the options for a new methodology for understanding human life is the psychology of the subject. Today, in Russian psychological science, the category of the subject plays a system-forming role, and this is not
  15. Student psychologist as a subject of educational and professional activity
    In modern pedagogy and pedagogical psychology, the traditional scheme of relations between teachers and students has long been abandoned, when the teacher acts as the "bearer" of knowledge and its active "guide" to the consciousness of students, i.e. acts as a "subject of the educational process", and students only "perceive" the proposed knowledge, while actually remaining passive
  16. Chemist as a subject of activity
    Chemists are people whose activities are directly related to matter and its transformations. A true chemist always “feels the substance” (Eremin, 2010). Chemical abilities existed before the development of chemistry as a science and were manifested in a tendency to professions “man-substance”, to manipulate matter in order to use its useful properties (Korobeinikova, Lisichkin, 2004, p. 69).
  17. Pishchita AN, Goncharov NG. The evolution of the legal regulation of healthcare in Russia. - Historical and legal aspects, 2007
    Introduction The history of the development and establishment of legal regulation of healthcare in Russia. The evolution of regulatory support for healthcare in Russia until 1857 The evolution of regulatory support for healthcare in Russia after 1857. The evolution of the healthcare management system in Russia (Historical and legal aspects) Activities of management entities
  18. Acmeologist as a subject of activity in the acmeological service
    Consideration of an acmeologist as a subject of activity within the framework of an acmeological service involves an appeal to his duties, responsibilities, rights, as well as personal and professional characteristics. In his professional activity, an acmeologist is obliged: - to be guided by the Constitution of the Russian Federation, government and regulatory documents regulating the activities of relevant structures,
Medical portal "MedguideBook" © 2014-2019
info@medicine-guidebook.com